In-Text Citations To strengthen your journal critique, you may want to quote or paraphrase sections from the original article. What was different in methods or analysis, what was similar? Figures dramatically enhance the graphic appeal of a scientific paper. Method mongering paper: describes a method with the aim of promoting it to other scholars in the field. Go straight to that section next time you open the document. This is perhaps obvious when the paper reports on a well planned research project.
Pitch your idea in a succinct way, as this will be your chance to impress the editor with your writing ability. Results, Discussion, and Conclusions In most journals the results section is separate from the discussion section. It demands a high level of in-depth analysis and a well-structured presentation of arguments. There are very good reasons why research articles have followed the sequence outlined above for decades, so you might want to conform to this approach. At some point in your scholarly career, you likely will get asked to review an article for a journal.
Most obviously, the range and specialisation of the journal should coincide in important ways with your own research, but finding a perfect fit is also a matter of approach, perspective, ideals and other more subtle aspects of research and writing. Does it meet the criteria the journal lists for publication, both in terms of focus and interest, but also in terms of, for example, the word limit and language accuracy? Abstract Sometimes written as an afterthought, the abstract is of extreme importance as in many instances this section is what is initially previewed by readership to determine if the remainder of the article is worth reading. End with the page numbers. So, in addition to being nice, it is in your best interest. If you findyourself endlessly polishing and not moving on, plan what to dothe next day. There should be complete transparency when describing the study. Authors focus on one key issue which is important to them and learn even more about it through the process of researching and writing an article; first time authors also learn a new set of skills — researching and writing for publication.
One way you can think about it is that the discussion section allows you to step back from the results section and reflect on the broader story or themes of your results and how they tie together. Also, references to unpublished work, to documents in the grey literature technical reports , or to any source that the reader will have difficulty finding or understanding should be avoided. Refrain from using direct quotations of text from the journal article. It is essential to understand the main points and arguments of the article for accuracy during summation. What new knowledge does it bring to the academic community? Look for unanswered questions in the article. What is my argument thesis? Related Posts © 2006 - 2019 , All Rights Reserved. The number of trade journals out there is staggering.
Despite such idiosyncrasies, knowing a few things about the purposes and format of a journal article will help you get published. While it may safely be assumed that the human genome is the same worldwide, whether the results of a local quality improvement project have wider relevance requires careful consideration and argument. And if you really like it, why not copy it? Correct referencing is proof that the author is aware of relevant previous work and is actually capable of defining a truly novel contribution. Choose a topic that you enjoy, are experienced in, and has not been extensively covered in the literature. Be sure to carefully address all relevant results, not just the statistically significant ones or the ones that support your hypotheses. . Only Qualified Specialists Article Critique Example One of the ways of simplifying the whole process of completing the assignment is using an article critique example.
Reviewers consider the following five criteria to be the most important in decisions about whether to accept manuscripts for publication: 1 the importance, timeliness, relevance, and prevalence of the problem addressed; 2 the quality of the writing style i. Some authors think that citing the work of others detracts from the novelty of their own contribution. Definitely, but you will have a huge sense of satisfaction when you see your article in print. That is why it is so simple to make one of many mistakes, while completing an article critique. She Tweets as tanyagolashboza and has her own. For example, do not include extraneous information about performance or prevention if your research does not actually address those things.
References should be used wisely. In scientific writing, it's important to clearly summarize the hypotheses the researchers outlined before undertaking the research, as well as the procedures used in following through with the project. An abstract is highly condensed and cannot provide the same level of detail regarding the research and its conclusions that a summary can. The titles for these sub-sections are usually bold and in a larger font than the remaining text. In particular, leave out a detailed description of research methodology so that no-one else can reproduce your work.
You may therefore need to seek assistance from mentors, colleagues and perhaps a professional academic or scientific proofreader to help you polish your writing to a publication standard that will benefit your career and your scholarly community. Adding references where not needed and — even worse — not adding references where needed is bound to lead to confusion and misinterpretation of your statements. Take notes as you read and highlight or underline main ideas. This section should consist of a brief summary of the critique you are going to provide. Although it is a good idea for the authors to have justification and a rationale for their procedures, these should be saved for inclusion into the discussion section, not to be discussed in the methods section. Like in case of , you can also make a to jot down what you would like to communicate through this article.